Building a Business That Supports Your Life: The Duncan & Stone Story

Building a Business That Supports Your Life: The Duncan & Stone Story

A year after leaving his job to run Duncan & Stone full time, Garrett wanted out. The business had tripled in 2021. Customers were buying its keepsake journals, and the company was growing. On paper, the decision to become an entrepreneur appeared to be working.

At home, it felt different. Garrett was handling fulfillment, customer service, and an expanding list of responsibilities. He had become so consumed by making the company succeed that his wife, Stephanie, reminded him why they had started: to give him more freedom and help him become a more present father.

The business was taking him further from that goal.

In his conversation with Aaron Spivak on the Founder to Founder podcast, Garrett explains how that happened and how he began changing it. His experience offers a useful perspective on product focus, working with family, and deciding how much growth is actually enough.

The Moment That Started Everything

Garrett’s interest in entrepreneurship became personal one evening in 2015. He came home from work, spent a little time with his young son, and soon heard that it was time for bed.

There was nothing particularly wrong with his job. He liked the people and worked in the supplier community around Walmart and Sam’s Club’s headquarters in Northwest Arkansas. He was also surrounded by founders whose enthusiasm for their products made an impression on him.

But that evening exposed a gap between his daily routine and the life he wanted. His available time with his children felt too limited. He wanted more control over how he showed up as a husband, father, and member of his community.

Garrett and Stephanie began exploring possibilities. They researched business ideas, attended a real estate investing event, and discussed what freedom would look like in practical terms. They sold their house, moved into a fixer-upper, and bought a rental property as part of that exploration.

The business that eventually changed their lives was still several years away. What came first was a clear reason to search for something different.

Two Families, One Side Project

By 2019, Garrett and Stephanie were regularly looking at product opportunities. Stephanie used Helium 10 to research Amazon, while both were interested in what they might create and sell.

Their friends Sarah and Garland Autry brought another piece of the puzzle. Sarah had a small Etsy business and a strong creative instinct. Together, the two couples saw an opportunity to build an ecommerce brand around keepsake journals.

They formed Duncan & Stone in 2019 and made their first website sale on February 26, 2020. Initially, Garrett kept his job. With three sons and household expenses, he wanted to see whether the business could develop before depending on it full time.

The work happened around family life. After putting the children to bed, Garrett and Stephanie opened their laptops, spoke with their overseas manufacturer, and worked on their Shopify store and Amazon presence.

Those evenings were demanding, but Garrett remembers them with enthusiasm. Building something tangible with his wife and friends was exciting. Their children even helped pack orders. The work had a purpose they could feel, long before the company became their main source of income.

Recognising When It Was Time to Commit

The first holiday season gave the founders something to celebrate. Then January 2021 arrived, and Garrett found himself answering to two demanding workplaces at once.

His employer needed his attention. Duncan & Stone’s customers needed answers. The growing business had responsibilities that could no longer fit neatly into the evening. He describes feeling overwhelmed by the competing demands.

When he told Stephanie how difficult it had become, her response was direct: it was time to quit his job.

Garrett was initially taken aback. The company was generating sales and some profit, but money was going back into inventory. The founders were not yet drawing salaries. Leaving employment still involved uncertainty.

They examined the business’s direction and discussed the decision with their partners. Garrett committed to giving it a year, knowing that his supplier-industry experience offered a potential route back into employment if necessary.

His decision followed evidence of demand and an honest look at their circumstances. Keeping his job had helped them test the opportunity. Eventually, maintaining both roles became a constraint of its own.

Growth Became a Personal Test

Going full time brought a pressure Garrett had underestimated. Once people knew he had left his job, the company’s performance began to feel like a verdict on him.

He needed it to work. That urgency gradually overtook the enjoyment he had felt while building the business in the evenings.

As CEO, he was also fulfilling orders, handling customer service, and trying to drive growth. His responsibilities expanded faster than his understanding of how to share them. He describes becoming obsessive about the company and increasingly difficult to work with.

By the end of 2021, Duncan & Stone had tripled, yet Garrett disliked working on it. He told the team he could not continue in the same way.

Stephanie’s observations made the problem harder to dismiss. The plan had been to create a healthier, more available father and husband. Instead, entrepreneurship had made him less present.

That experience complicates the usual picture of business success. Sales growth can happen alongside exhaustion and deteriorating enjoyment. A company may be moving forward while the person running it loses sight of what the progress was supposed to achieve.

Learning to Share the Work

The turning point involved recognising how much of the business depended on the founders personally doing everything.

Garrett says they did not yet understand outsourcing or how to scale their operations. They knew how to work hard and solve immediate problems. They needed help building a structure that could support more customers without continually increasing the pressure on them.

He began asking questions, seeking coaching, and learning from other entrepreneurs. As the team outsourced work and removed responsibilities from his plate, the situation started to improve.

The important change was accepting that his role could evolve. Being responsible for the business did not require him to personally carry out every task inside it.

For a founder, that can be a difficult adjustment. Early progress often comes from willingness to do whatever needs doing. As demand grows, the same habit can leave the owner overwhelmed. Garrett’s experience shows why learning to distribute work belongs within the growth plan itself, rather than being postponed until there is finally spare time.

A Clear Product Vision Gave the Brand Direction

Alongside the operational challenges, Duncan & Stone benefited from Sarah’s clear understanding of the customer.

As someone who kept her own family’s memories, she wanted childhood books that felt timeless, clean, and attractive enough to leave on a table. She saw room for products that avoided designs likely to feel dated after a few years.

That vision gave the brand a specific starting point: guided keepsakes for recording meaningful life experiences. Baby showers, family milestones, and other gift-giving occasions provided natural reasons to buy them.

Garrett credits his partners for this direction. He did not design the products himself. Sarah and Stephanie brought strengths that helped turn a broad interest in ecommerce into a recognisable brand.

Focus also helped the team assess opportunities. There were plenty of products they could potentially sell, but each new idea needed to fit the business they were building. Over time, the range expanded into areas such as travel, reading, and family recipes, while preserving the broader purpose of helping people capture memories.

The Legacy Journal Made an Emotional Need Tangible

One of Duncan & Stone’s standout products grew from a personal experience. Sarah’s grandfather had died before she had the opportunity to ask him many of the questions she later wished she could.

That experience inspired the legacy journal, developed in 2021. Its guided prompts give someone a way to record their life story for children, grandchildren, and other loved ones.

The appeal goes beyond having a place to write. Giving the journal communicates interest in someone’s experiences. It offers a practical starting point for families who want to preserve those stories but have never quite known how to begin.

Product quality supports that purpose. Garrett describes cloth covers, substantial pages, and a clean appearance intended to make the journal feel like a lasting keepsake.

The team also faced a marketing challenge: customers did not always know what to search for. Established terms such as baby memory books were easier to connect with existing demand. Other products required the brand to help people recognise a need they had felt without necessarily having a name for it.

Choosing a Channel and Learning It Properly

Duncan & Stone launched through both its website and Amazon, with Amazon chosen early as a key sales channel.

The founders wanted to reach customers where they were already shopping. They sought guidance on setting up the brand and invested effort in establishing a meaningful presence there.

Garrett does not present that choice as a universal formula. It was a direction the team selected and learned to execute. Their product vision and channel strategy gave them a manageable place to concentrate their attention.

There is a useful lesson in that combination. Finding an appealing product is only part of building a consumer business. The team also needs a way to help customers discover it, understand its purpose, and feel confident buying it.

For Duncan & Stone, the emotional value of memory keeping needed to translate into a product shoppers could recognise as a thoughtful gift. The journals made that value concrete, while the sales channels helped put them within reach.

Protecting Relationships Takes Deliberate Effort

Working with a spouse and close friends brought advantages, but Garrett took the risks seriously before the business began. He spent months discussing the idea with mentors and considering what might happen if money or disagreements strained the relationships.

Once the company was operating, another challenge emerged: business conversations could follow them everywhere.

Stephanie was both his wife and his teammate. Their cofounders were also friends they spent time with outside work. Without boundaries, almost any gathering could become an opportunity to discuss orders, products, or the next problem.

Garrett had to learn when to engage as a business leader and when to step back into being a husband or father. He describes a gradual process of understanding himself, choosing better moments for work conversations, and becoming more intentional about daily routines.

Support from other founders helped broaden his attention to physical health, emotional wellbeing, and relationships. Those areas had received too little consideration during the intense early period. Giving them space became part of building a life he actually wanted to keep living.

Deciding What Enough Looks Like

Garrett remains competitive. He wants Duncan & Stone to improve, and seeing a competitor do well still gets his attention. But he increasingly questions the reason behind a growth target.

What would a larger business make possible? What would it require from him? Would the trade-off support the priorities that started this journey?

His original ambition was for the company to provide for his family, challenge him, and allow him to invest in his wife, sons, and community. That gives him a more personal measure of success than comparing revenue with every founder around him.

During the conversation, Spivak distinguishes contentment from complacency. Garrett’s experience illustrates the difference. Appreciating what he has built can coexist with wanting to improve it. He can pursue better results without making every missed target a judgment on his worth.

By the time of the interview, he was able to travel to Miami with his son and enjoy the business again. Those moments reflected the freedom he had hoped to create years earlier.

Taking Responsibility Without Carrying Everything

Asked what he would tell his twenty-two-year-old self, Garrett returns to control. He wishes he had learned earlier to take care of the things within his influence and release the outcomes he could not dictate.

He had spent years carrying pressure around family, relationships, and business. Some responsibility was necessary. Trying to guarantee every outcome was exhausting.

That distinction runs through the Duncan & Stone story. Garrett could choose to explore a business idea, commit to it, seek advice, share the workload, and protect time with his family. He could keep improving his decisions without securing every future result in advance.

The company’s progress eventually gave him more choices. Learning how to use those choices brought him closer to the life he wanted. For Garrett, the achievement includes a growing brand, but it also includes being able to enjoy the people and experiences that made building it worthwhile.

Watch the Full Episode